2008 Feedback

Designing out Waste is a Waste of Time

Wednesday, 30th January 2008

Designing out waste is not a waste of time. This was the general conclusion of the debate of over 90 industry representatives interested in solving this problem. However the debate clearly identified some barriers and obstacles that need to be overcome, to start to correctly address and improve this problem in the East Midlands. It is clearly no single organisations responsibility. The industry will only address these obstacles effectively in collaborative environments, where disciplines can work together to mitigate through innovative practices and working through problems. EMCBE recognise ‘the clients’ have a responsibility because they hold the budgets but there is an element of everyone taking responsibility for this important agenda. 

We will work with partners to the problems. EMCBE needs the support and commitment of industry and we urge you to take part in EMCBE activities to progress these recommendations.

EMCBE has a very important role in the region. Key stakeholders in the construction industry formed EMCBE in 2004 to act as the East Midlands Industry voice. The strategic role of EMCBE is an important position for the industry. Its prime function is to be the facilitator between the regional construction industry and work with National, Regional and Local Government to coordinate important industry issues. Over 300 networks operate across the region with good intentions to, share best practice, network and work with industry. EMCBE works with major stakeholders in these networks to disseminate information but also collect intelligence and work with the relevant Government departments to shape the support provided to the East Midlands Construction Industry. EMCBE has a range of mechanisms to work with relevant Policy organisation such as East Midlands Development Agency. 

The Sector Implementation Plan is an important regional document outlining the current strategic issues faced by industry, in its desire to improve. The document then identifies areas were investment is required to change and over come barriers to improve the performance of the Construction Sector.

The recommendations listed above clearly identify the areas EMCBE brings forward into the Sector Implementation Plan.

Finally I would like to thank all those who participated in the debate, the panelists who set the agenda and position of the, policy makers and enforcers, clients supply chain representatives who are often put under pressure to solve the situation. The best practice shared by these presenters was very informative. I certainly enjoyed the evening and will keep you informed as we take the specific agenda and wider agenda forward. EMCBE main mechanism for doing this at this stage will be through its monthly newsletter; BE Constructive

Signup www.emcbe.com

David J Walker MBE

This conference was support by:

Envirowise
Responsible Solutions
emda
EMCBE
Bowmer and Kirkland
National Green Specification Green Spec 

The Panelists were:

John Nicholls, Leicester Regeneration Company   Chairman
Mike Atkinson, Bowmer & Kirkland Construction Divn
Andrew Mellor, PRP Architects
Steve Millward, Jewson Limited
Michael Rogers, Joynes Pike & Associates Ltd
Chris Ward-Brown, East Midlands Development Agency (emda)
Clare Watkins, Environment Agency 

Organisations attending were:

Aggregate Industries UK Ltd

Alpha Construction

Anthony Short & Partners

Backs Builders

Balfour Beatty Civil Engineering Ltd

Bloor Holdings Ltd

Bodill & Sons Ltd

Bowmer & Kirkland Construction Divn

CMEC Demolition

Constructing Excellence in the Built Environment

Danaher and Walsh Ltd

David Granger Architectural Design Limited

Derby City Council

Derby Homes

Dukeries Building Company Ltd

Dukeries Building Company Ltd

Dukeries Building Company Ltd

East Midlands Development Agency (emda)

Environment Agency

Envirowise

Faithful & Gould

Galliford Try Construction Ltd

Gleeson Building

Hallam J H (Contracts) Ltd

Herbert Baggaley Construction Limited

Interserve

Interserve Projects Ltd

Jewson Limited

Joynes Pike & Associates Ltd

Kaberry Group

Kier Eastern

Kingfisher Construction Services

Laser Build Ltd

Leap Ahead

Leicester Regeneration Company

Loughborough University

M Wright & Sons Ltd

Maber Architects

Mainland Construction LTD

Marriott Construction

Matthew Montague Architects (MMA)

Morgan Ashurst

Morrison Design Limited

National Green Specification NGS GreenSpec

Network Rail

Newlife Regeneration Construction Ltd

Newline Civil Engineering (Midlands) Ltd

North Midland Construction Plc

Parkinson Dodson & Associates

PRP Architects

Responsible Solutions Limited

Rogers Clarke Lander Ltd

Scott Wilson

Sir Robert McAlpine Ltd

Sustainable Technology Solutions

University of Derby

Van Elle Group

Vinden Partnership

WasteCycle

White Young Green

The debate Celebrated two years of hard work of over 15 main contractors who have been involved in an East Midlands Construction Resource Efficiency Club sponsored by Envirowise. The Contractors in the two years have done there bit and saved thousands of pounds through applying resource efficiency principles and practices. 

More information on the East Midlands Construction Resource Efficiency Club: http://www.emcbe.com/resource-efficiency.html

The Aim of the Debate

The debates mission was to provide the environment for an interesting and stimulating debate where best practice can be shared, issues identified and recommendations can be brought forward to support the development of the East Midlands Construction Industry. 

The Agenda for the Debate

The following agenda items were outlined by key representatives responsible for the debate:

  • Chair of the Debate: John Nicholls, Leicester Regeneration Company
    • CO2 Emissions
    • Legal compliance
    • Contractor legal obligations
    • Designers have the responsibilities up-stream
  • Presenter 1: Chris Ward-Brown, emda
    • Overview of the regional economic strategy
    • Sustainable economic development
    • Objective to lead the East Midlands to be a top 20 Region by the year 2010 (35 – 28th position)
    • Indicator of sustainable economic wellbeing
    • Consequences and failure of design waste
    • Emda are charged with spatial and economic development
    • Sustainability cutting out waste is fundamentally embedded in RE Strategy
    • Construction is the biggest industry in the UK economy
    • Emda supporting change management
    • EMCBE
    • REM
    • Business Link
    • Waste
      • It’s about not wasting time
      • New innovations
      • Waste and urban regeneration
  • Presenter 2: Andrew Mellor, PRP Architects
    • China
    • New construction techniques
    • New skills
    • Time
    • Certifying quality material
    • Modules – to reduce waste – size of pasterboard
    • Environmental – the way plasterboard is being used (i.e. flooding rotating plasterboard)
    • Educating the Client
    • Contractors
  • Presenter 3: Mike Rogers, Joynes Pike Associates
    • What is waste and what is not waste
    • Encouraging the re-use of brownfield sites
    • Definition of waste
    • Definition (slide….)
  • Presenter 4: Mike Atkinson, Bowmer & Kirkland
    • Overview of contractors view
    • Educate clients
    • Brickwork sizes
    • Offsite manufacture
    • Design build – education
    • Maximize profits
    • Contractor wants to generate revenue a good contractor will look to reduce cost savings
    • Space for recycling
    • Early involvement of contractors t reduce variations (time, money and skills)
  • Presenter 5: Steve Millward, Jewsons
    • Talk about a project
    • Spin offs
    • Communication
    • Reduced waste / product damage
    • Order notes
    • Jewson took back all materials
    • Summing lorry times
    • WRAP – zero waste site using
  • Presenter 6: Clare Watkins, Environment Agency
    • Waste is not a key issue?
    • Construction produces 30% of England’s waste.
  • Open Debate
  • Chairs Closing Remarks/Summary
  • David Walker: Closing Statement
Chairman’s Opening Statement

The Question for this debate is Designing Out Waste is a Waste of time? 

Minimising waste in the construction process is an imperative for a variety of reasons. 

  • Its costs money to buy the items you are wasting
  • It costs to through them away
  • The impact on the environment, through CO2 used to make deliver and disposal.
  • Degree of legal compliance but of these issues impact on the contractor.
  • They effect the contractors bottom line
  • Upstream of the construction process the design community has a responsibility to design in these savings and work with the manufactures to ensure the products support the aim of reducing waste.

The aim of the debate is to raise the issues in the design community, to share information and best practice but more importantly to brief EMCBE about the Regional Actions where support is required by the industry to remove the barriers and obstacles faced. Outcomes could be further training events, support for industry and communication with Government on the issues and how they can support change.

Six people on the Panel for the Debate were asked to set the scene and their position through a five minute presentation. 

Presenter 1:

Chris Ward-Brown

Construction Policy Advisor, East Midlands Development Agency (emda)

Chris Ward-Brown is currently East Midlands Development Agency’s Policy Advisor on the Construction Sector. This role involves putting in place a wide range of interventions to support growth and improvement in the sector. In addition, emda are the lead English Regional Development Agency for the sector, a significant part of Chris’ work involves liaison with UK government departments and the other English RDA’s.

Prior to this, Chris was an Innovation Manager working specifically with the Creative Industries sector in the East Midlands. This role involved a very broad range of projects and activities – from major capital projects, to enterprise support programmes supporting young people with limited life choices. Prior to his work at emda, he worked for a number of years in local government in the creative and cultural sector and also managed a major events and performance centre.

 

Presenter 2

Andrew Mellor

Associate Director, PRP Architects

Andrew joined PRP in December 2004 and became Associate Director in 2007. He leads PRP’s environmental services team and also sits on the Sustainability Steering Group and chairs the London office’s Sustainability Group. 

Andrew’s experience was gained through delivering sustainability projects including large scale regeneration, commercial and residential developments. His current role involves developing sustainability strategies on projects, including energy efficiency, low an zero carbon technologies, water and waste management and material specification. Besides the environmental issues, his role involves consideration of the social and economic aspects of sustainability.

 

 

 Presenter 3 

Mike Rogers

Technical Director, Joynes Pike Associates

Mike has a roving role within Joynes Pike Associates being responsible for Environmental policy across the Eastern offices. Mike’s role is to ensure that the development objectives are met for clients in line with UK policy.

Following an initial period of employment in the overseas mining sector, Mike has 16 years experience within the UK and has seen the contaminated land regime evolve. This has included the implications of the waste management regulations on Brownfield redevelopment and the effect these regulations have on the Clients who have to operate within them.

Mike has served on the Midland Geotechnical Society and Association of Geotechnical Specialists Committee and presented numerous internal an external training courses as well as being a former visiting lecturer at Loughborough University.

 Presenter 4

Mike Atkinson

Contracts Manager, Bowmer and Kirkland

Mike has 20 years experience working in the industry as a main contractor. His experience covers a wide range of Projects including Education, Leisure, Retail, Commercial, Industrial and Civil Engineering.

For the past five years he has been a Contracts Manager for Bowmer and Kirkland and is currently overseeing the conversion of a range of Grade 2 and Grade 2* listed buildings to form a new campus for Derby College.

 Presenter 5

Steve Millward

Sustainability and Quality Director, Jewsons Limited

Steve Millward commenced employment with A Sharpe and Co Timber Merchants as a Management Trainee in 1971. During this time he became a member of the institute of Wood Science.

Following a variety of roles within Jewsons Ltd, Steve was appointed Regional Managing Director for the South West of England in 1966. This was followed by a series of senior roles in the area of Product until Steve was appointed as Commercial Director for Jewson and then Managing Director of CTD Tiles in 2000.

The position of Environmental and Quality Director was created by Jewson Ltd; a subsidiary of Saint-Gobain Building Distribution UK (SGBD UIK), in 2003 and Steve was the first appointment to this position. Steve is the author of the SGBD UK Environmental and Quality Policy and for delivering the Strategy that underpins this Policy.

Presenter 6

Clare Watkins

Principal Waste & Resources Officer, Environment Agency

Clare has been an environmental practitioner for 13 years, working with businesses across many sectors on how to get the most from waste and resource management. Clare is currently the Principal Waste and Resources Officer in Strategic Environmental Planning for the Anglian Region of the Environment Agency. Her responsibilities include project manager for the National SITEwise II initiative which addresses waste issues in the construction industry.

 EMCBE Statement

In September 2005 I spoke on ‘Sustainable Construction’ at a conference, at which time it was alleged that only 34% of people in our industry had heard of sustainable development and construction.

If that was indeed true then, although the statistic implied that over 1.5 million people in the industry had not heard of the issues – which I found very difficult to believe, then it surely cannot be true now, 2 years on.

In 2005, I also suggested that, as with many other construction change and improvement movements, the theorists – experts, consultants, advisors, et al – had ‘hijacked’ the sustainability agenda and made it a mystery, a business opportunity in itself, when it is in fact pretty straightforward.

If that was true then, then it is certainly even more so the case now, with ‘initiative overload’. Just spend a few minutes on the internet.

In September 2005, I concluded that: “We know what needs to be done, let’s just get on and do it”.

For the past 16 months, the EMCBE has been endeavouring to eliminate the ‘bullshit’ – green anaerobic bullshit, of course – from the language and some of the issues – through its ‘Sustainability Speak’ section of the electronic newsletter, EMCBEConstructive, which reaches an audience of 8,000 on a monthly basis.

We shall continue to provide that approach, which readers say is very straightforward and helpful, for as long as we can.

We are also about to embark on a project to understand and map exactly what is happening throughout the Region in respect of the sustainable construction agenda, including : products, methods, solutions, processes, innovations and so on, and to share that intelligence with everybody.

Waste minimisation and ideally elimination is just one but important part of the Triple Bottom Line challenge of People–Planet–Profit, or social-environmental-financial.

There is much that the construction industry is doing to improve itself, despite what the critics might say, but so much more that needs to be done.

Your attendance and participation at this event, which I hope you enjoyed, would indicate that you are taking the challenges seriously.

Thanks for coming, and please be ready to help the EMCBE with its work if called upon, starting with input to the regional mapping exercise.

We shall be in touch.

The UK construction industry consists of over 250 000 firms employing 2.1 million people in a multitude of roles. The sector is defined as one which embraces the construction materials and products; suppliers and producers; building services manufacturers, providers and installers; contractors, sub-contractors, professionals, advisors and construction clients and those organisations that are relevant to the design, build, operation and refurbishment of buildings.

The UK construction output is the second largest in the EU and contributes 8.2% of the nations GVA (Gross Value Added). UK designers, civil engineers, contractors, component & product manufacturers have a worldwide reputation for working overseas, providing high-tech solutions to environmental, transport & building projects. (Statistics on the sector are available from the BERR Construction Statistics and Economics pages.)

 

Firefox Correction